Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Blue Cave Italian menu

5 dishes across 5 sections Moderately expensive Italian Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Blue Cave Italian photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Blue Cave Italian photo menu 1 Blue Cave Italian photo menu 2 Blue Cave Italian photo menu 3 Blue Cave Italian photo menu 4 Blue Cave Italian photo menu 5 Blue Cave Italian photo menu 6 Blue Cave Italian photo menu 7

Appetizers/Salads 8 dishes

  • Panelle $9.00

    Sicilian crispy chickpea fritters, fresh ricotta & lemon zest.

  • Arancini $16.00

    Sicily’s favorite street food! Italian arborio rice stuffed with ragu & mozzarella, breaded & fried, served with tomato sauce

  • Calamari Fritti $17.00

    Crispy lightly fried calamari served with marinara sauce for dipping

  • Burrata e Prosciutto $16.00

    Burrata, arugula, prosciutto, walnuts, balsamic glaze, & crostini

  • Insalata di Pere $15.00

    Mixed greens, gorgonzola, walnuts, pear, & balsamic dressing

  • Insalata di Barbabietole $15.00

    Arugula, beets, walnuts, feta, & honey balsamic dressing

  • Polpette al Sugo $12.00

    Homemade meatballs with tomato sauce, parmigiano & ricotta

  • Cannolo Caprese $15.00

    Cannolo shell filled with creamy burrata, served with cherry tomatoes, pistachio, & balsamic glaze

Pasta 9 dishes

  • Gnocchi Bolognese $28.00

    Homemade ricotta gnocchi, slow simmered beef, veal, & pork ragu.

  • Pasta Alla Norma $24.00

    Housemade cavatelli pasta, eggplant, tomato basil sauce, topped with ricotta salata.

  • Fettuccine al Tartufo Nero $29.00

    Housemade fettuccine in a creamy butter sauce topped with shaved black truffles Limited availability

  • Spaghetti al Pesto Trapanese $24.00

    Spaghetti with Sicilian pesto of almonds, cherry tomatoes, basil, parmigiano, garlic & olive oil, topped with burrata

  • Spaghetti al Pomodoro $14.00

    Spaghetti with San Marzano tomato sauce

  • Fettuccine al Granchio $29.00

    Housemade fettuccine with crab meat, Castelvetrano green olives, cherry tomatoes, & fresh chili pepper

  • Orecchiette al Salmone $25.00

    Little ears pasta with fresh salmon in a creamy cherry tomato & cognac sauce

  • Orecchiette alla Montecarlo $25.00

    Little ears pasta with ragu, cream, & basil pesto

  • Lasagna Bolognese Pasta $26.00

    Spinach pasta layered between ragu, bechamel, & parmigiano

Main Course 6 dishes

  • Brasato di Manzo $34.00

    Prime beef chuck short ribs, slowly braised, gravy, & truffle mashed potatoes.

  • Filetto di Branzino $29.00

    Mediterranean bass sautéed with cherry tomatoes, black olives, white wine & lemon sauce served over truffle puréed potatoes and topped with asparagus

  • RIsotto del Giorno

    Chef's creation changes daily.

  • Braciola $25.00

    Thin sliced beef stuffed with garlic, herbs, breadcrumbs and a blend of cheeses, rolled and slow simmered in tomato sauce, served with orecchiette pasta

  • Scaloppine di Pollo $27.00

    Tender chicken breast lightly floured cooked in light lemon sauce with capers over mashed potatoes

  • Pollo alla Milanese $29.00

    Breaded chicken cutlet served with arugula, cherry tomatoes, shaved parmigiano, & lemon dressing

Sides 3 dishes

  • Asparagi Grigliati $9.00

    Grilled asparagus

  • Purè di Patate $8.00

    Truffle mashed potatoes

  • Insalata Mista $7.00

    Mixed greens with tomato and cucumber.

Dessert 3 dishes

  • Tiramisu $9.00

    Classic Italian tiramisu

  • Cannoli $9.00

    Cannoli shelled filled with sweetened ricotta cheese, chocolate chips, & pistachios.

  • Gelati $9.00

    Ask your server about today's selection.

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian dining experience in Lewiston, Blue Cave Italian at 810 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092, is definitely worth checking out. This cozy Italian restaurant has built a reputation for serving comforting dishes that range from small plates perfect for sharing to hearty main courses that satisfy any craving. Whether you’re in the mood for a fresh vegetarian option, a classic pasta dish, or a perfectly cooked entrée paired with a glass of wine, Blue Cave Italian makes it easy to enjoy a meal your way. The restaurant offers flexible service options including dine-in, takeout, delivery, curbside pickup, and even outdoor seating for those sunny days, making it convenient for any occasion.

The atmosphere at Blue Cave Italian is relaxed yet lively, giving off a genuine Italian vibe that makes every visit feel special. Guests often mention the warm, friendly staff who are always ready to recommend dishes or suggest a cocktail from their well-stocked bar. Speaking of drinks, the menu doesn’t disappoint with offerings like wine, beer, cocktails, and hard liquor, allowing you to pair your meal exactly how you like. For coffee lovers, there’s a selection of freshly brewed options to enjoy either during a casual meal or as a relaxing end to a long day. The combination of comfort food and carefully crafted drinks ensures there’s something for everyone, whether you’re dining solo, with friends, or bringing the whole family.

One of the standout features of Blue Cave Italian is how it blends traditional Italian flavors with a modern touch, keeping every plate vibrant and full of flavor. From the moment you walk in, the inviting space and thoughtfully arranged seating make it easy to settle in and enjoy a leisurely meal. With the flexibility to choose from onsite dining or the convenience of takeout and delivery, Blue Cave Italian caters to every lifestyle. The menu’s variety, paired with the relaxed yet authentic Italian vibe, makes it a spot that locals and visitors alike return to again and again, eager to experience both the food and the friendly atmosphere.

Other menus in Lewiston

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Lewiston listings
Call Menu Directions